And to be honest, I was thankful for that because I thought maybe I’d done something wrong.

Most reviews are glowing, but some are more critical. According to reviews and comments, they are supposed to be large, domed, and extremely peanut buttery thanks to the fact that they are primarily peanut butter. Texture of Ovenly Inspired Peanut Butter Cookies Flavor and Textureīut since I probably won’t make it to Brooklyn for a while, I went ahead and tried the recipe made famous by Smitten Kitchen and Ovenly’s cookbook. Personally, I’d rather apply that to a flight to Brooklyn and visit the bakery. If you have that much to spend on peanut butter cookies, they’re probably worth it. And guess what? If you don’t want to bake the cookies you can just order a dozen for a mere $59. Now they’re trendy, thanks to the Brooklyn bakery, Ovenly. Advertisement I’ve always considered flourless peanut butter cookies a quick and easy substitute for traditional “with-flour” peanut butter cookies.